Mama Mia`s Pizza in Geneseo

It's ok. Nice people who work here. I didn't like that they only had pizza ready. They have other foods but it would take to long to cook. Also good prices.but the pizza is like eating paper. It's huge slices but very thin.

Possibly one of the worst subs I've ever had. They dont have steak subs, who doesnt have steak subs? Over all, if you want cheap, fast delivery with a dry tasteless sub then mama mias is the place for you. Very disappointed

A friendly atmosphere but the pizza crust is paper thin and antipasto salad was 80% lettuce. Prefer a heartier crust. I would go back and try something else on the menu.

You'd think I'd avoid this place more seeing as my landlord owns it and already takes enough of my money, but seriously, those garlic knots are to die for. And as far as a slice of upstate pizza can go, it's pretty good. It's also one of the only restaurants that's opened late enough for party-goers to crash in for a bit, save for University Hots, which is incredibly convenient if you're into the Geneseo nightlife.

Always good. Every damn time.

Best pizza ever

Great eatery

Leaf peeping just yards away from SUNY Geneseo and craving Italian at 11 a.m. Mama Mia is not just a great Broadway Play, it is also a delicious place for Pizza (Slice or Pie), Pasta, Paninis, Salads, and more. Spaghetti and meatballs was not specifically on the menu, but the Owner gladly whipped up a batch with red sauce, 1 oz. meatballs and perfect temperature sausage that provided flavors rarely duplicated in my many travels. Go here hungry, pay $0.50 at a parking meter and enjoy!

Thin NYC pizza that you will enjoy! Slices sold daily and often.

We called at 10pm when they close at 11pm and the woman on the phone immediately said were closed and hung up. The girl on the phone said “hi, mama mias” so we said we wanted a pizza and she goes “we’re closed” and hung up the phone. Even tho they don’t close for another hour.

My favorite pizzeria. Barbeque wings are delicious as well.

Best pizza around, hasn't changed since I started going here in the late 90s

Pizza is the best in the area. Slightly annoying that they pick and choose when they want to deliver as you never can really count on it, but its worth it to go pick it up.

The food is delicious and the restaurant is clean along with the bathroom and the people are very friendly

The crust was a little thin, and just a little too well done so I couldn't eat the crust at the edge of the slice. Tasted very good though and fast and friendly service

Awesome New York style pizza!

A Geneseo staple. Always great pizza that can't be beat. Don't forget about the lunch special and blue cheese for dipping!

Goid pizza and pasta

Took my orders wrong twice, unfriendly service

Date of visit: Monday September 9, 2019. I walked in and walked right out. Kill the loud music dude.

Like with any restaurant in a small town with a rotating staff, sometimes you get good food and sometimes you don't.Like with any manager that churns out so many complaints from employees about sexist treatment, Mama Mia's has lost my patronage.

I've been going here for years.If you like NY style pizza then this is your place.

Our family loves a little Mia's routinely. Unique specialty pizzas and quick service.

The young lady (tall blonde) at the counter was super friendly. The ham sud I had was delicious and filled with ham. I would definitely ireturn.

Fantastic wings. Decent pizza.

One of the students working forgot to pull my slices for 10 minutes, older guy making pies pulls them out when I asked about them and gives me two free slices. Not to mention their the only place I know of to find proper N.Y. thin crust pizza. Sauce is on the savoury side, with good toppings.

This pizza is absolutely amazing...every single time! Thin crust and great sauce makes it a perfect! I highly recommend!

Great NY style pizza! Huge slices.

Best pizza in the area in my opinion. Great dough and sauce, not too greasy. Perfect!

Pizza is good. Inside needs to be remodeled. Feels old and dungeon like. It’s all college kids who don’t care, so it’s mediocre service. This place needs a serious makeover though.

The delivery took an hour and a half, and the sausage wasn't even real sausage. The wings were good, but the boneless weren't fully sauced.

Ordered assorted sub, first experience with Mama Missphenomenal sub, quick and friendly delivery.Bill

We waited 45 min and they wanted us to wait 10 more minutes because they gave our order away. They also made it feel like it was our fault. Will never go again.

Update: the pizza today was again just ok and the wings again we're very goods. I must add that the single bathroom is NOT very nice! Pizza is ok . The wings are very good!

Best pizza around, definitely beats leaning tower in Mount Morris !

Best pizza in the area. Very much like the dollar slices from NYC. I always swung by when I am visiting the area. If you don't like thin crust this place ain't for you.

Best pizza in the county, maybe even state.. Seriously, as close to,NYC pizza as u can get without the drive.. Slices are amazing

good thin crust pizza but this place is seriously a dump.....Kitchen area looks disgusting. Dirty old tables. Plus the other half of the restaurant is used for storage.. Would it kill the owner to renovate? I don’t know how the health department hasn’t closed this place down yet. I won’t be returning.

Great food, adorable seating area

Pizza not crispy. It was like eating uncooked dough. Eggplant parmesan was hard to eat. Don't think they peel the eggplant. Sauce was good and would have been great if it was cooked

pizza the best .wings too. delivered on time hotttt!!!!thank you!!!!!!!

Wings were ok , the pizza was very disappointing, in other words it sucked.

This place is the worse. They may have good food but you have to wait forever. Ad sometimes when you get it its still cold or worsesoggy

Delicious this crust pizza, large slices. Great prices!

Just keeps gettin better 30 yrs later!

This is the best pizza in town. This is the best pizza in the state. This may be the best pizza in the nation. If you like thin, chewy, screaming hot pizza in a charming brick cafe, this is it. The end.

serves good food with friendly hard working staff

Usually good but they put my Togo hot sub on a paper plate in a paper bag and didn't wrap it in foil. It was cold when I got home...and I think the dough has changed...sort of tasting like cardboard...needs salt or something...

Not what it used to be when I was growing up in geneseo, poor service and poor quality!

Pretty good pizza. Weird toilet.